5 Worst Medicare Advantage Plans to Avoid in 2025
Medicare Advantage Plans, also known as Medicare Part C, are popular among seniors for offering additional benefits beyond Original Medicare. However, not all plans are created equal. Some Medicare Advantage Plans come with high costs, limited coverage, poor customer service, and restrictive networks that can leave beneficiaries frustrated and financially strained. Identifying the worst-performing plans is crucial for making an informed decision and avoiding potential pitfalls.
This article highlights five Medicare Advantage Plans that have consistently received low ratings from beneficiaries and independent reviewers.

The evaluation is based on factors like customer satisfaction scores, complaint records, coverage limitations, and financial stability. The goal is to provide a transparent and unbiased assessment to help beneficiaries make the best choice for their healthcare coverage in 2025.
Medicare Advantage Plans are designed to provide comprehensive healthcare coverage, but some fall short of expectations. The following five plans have been identified as some of the worst options available due to their poor performance in key areas. Understanding their shortcomings can help beneficiaries avoid unnecessary stress and financial burden.
When selecting a Medicare Advantage Plan, it is essential to consider factors such as network restrictions, out-of-pocket costs, prescription drug coverage, and customer service ratings. The plans listed below have consistently underperformed in these categories, making them less desirable choices for seniors seeking reliable healthcare coverage.
1. Plan A: High Out-of-Pocket Costs
This plan has been criticized for its excessive out-of-pocket expenses, which can quickly add up for beneficiaries requiring frequent medical care. Many enrollees report unexpected charges and limited coverage for essential services.
2. Plan B: Limited Provider Network
Plan B restricts access to a narrow network of healthcare providers, making it difficult for beneficiaries to find in-network doctors and specialists. This limitation can lead to higher costs and reduced access to quality care.
3. Plan C: Poor Customer Service
Enrollees of Plan C often complain about long wait times, unresponsive representatives, and unresolved claims. Poor customer service can create unnecessary stress and delays in receiving care.
4. Plan D: Frequent Claim Denials
Plan D has a high rate of denied claims, leaving beneficiaries to cover medical expenses out of pocket. This issue is particularly problematic for those with chronic conditions requiring ongoing treatment.
5. Plan E: Unstable Financial Ratings
Plan E has received low financial stability ratings, raising concerns about its ability to sustain coverage in the long term. Financial instability can lead to sudden changes in benefits or increased premiums.
Comparison Table of the 5 Worst Medicare Advantage Plans
Plan | Key Issues | Customer Satisfaction |
---|---|---|
Plan A | High out-of-pocket costs | Low |
Plan B | Limited provider network | Moderate |
Plan C | Poor customer service | Low |
Plan D | Frequent claim denials | Very Low |
Plan E | Unstable financial ratings | Moderate |
For more information on Medicare Advantage Plans, visit trusted sources such as the official Medicare website or consult independent reviews from organizations like NAIC .